Every now and then, Netflix delivers a series that has you questioning absolutely everything. Who’s telling the truth? Who’s hiding something? And why does everyone seem so suspicious? 😂
Behind Her Eyes is one of those series. Based on Sarah Pinborough’s 2017 novel, this six-part psychological thriller packs romance, deception, mind games and more than a little anxiety into just a few episodes. I love a series that doesn’t give away all its secrets at the start, and this one certainly kept me entertained!
Is Behind Her Eyes worth watching? For me, it’s a definite yes — even if a couple of moments made me roll my eyes. And don’t worry: NO SPOILERS!
What’s Behind Her Eyes About?
Louise, a single mother, meets a stranger on a night out and they share a kiss. Things become rather complicated when she discovers he’s David, her new boss — and that he’s married. Then, through another unexpected encounter, she befriends his wife, Adele. Oh, what could possibly go wrong? 😂
There’s clearly more going on beneath the surface than anyone is willing to say. Louise finds herself caught between two people whose relationship seems anything but straightforward. Who should she trust? And how much does she really know about either of them?
The series stars Simona Brown, Eve Hewson and Tom Bateman, and it’s the sort of mystery that makes you want to watch just one more episode.
The Characters: Who Can You Trust?
The story focuses firmly on Louise, David and Adele. I liked how the three main characters have enough depth to keep you guessing about their motives. One moment you think you’ve worked someone out; the next, you’re questioning your judgement all over again.
There’s also Rob, an old friend of Adele’s who appears in flashbacks. There’s something strange about him from the beginning, and I couldn’t shake that feeling throughout the series.
I liked all three central characters straight away, even when I wasn’t sure whether I trusted them! The flashbacks gradually give us more information about their pasts, without simply handing us the answers.
For me, the series is like a well-executed jigsaw puzzle. With every episode, you get another little piece of the picture. I love that sort of storytelling.
Love, Lies and Psychological Mind Games
One thing I particularly enjoyed was how the series explores the psychology of relationships, from control and jealousy to outright lies. And it isn’t only romantic relationships that come under the microscope. Friendships, family ties and professional boundaries all play their part.
There’s plenty to question when it comes to David and Louise’s relationship. I found myself wondering whether the characters were being honest with each other, or even with themselves. Louise gets drawn deeper into a complicated situation, and the tension only grows.
It’s the uncertainty that makes this such an addictive psychological thriller. Just when you think you know what’s going on, something else makes you reconsider.
Is There Something Supernatural Going On?
The series has a supernatural edge, although it takes its time revealing how that fits into the mystery. I was praying it wasn’t going to turn out to be alien-related — I’ve seen too many promising thrillers ruined that way! 😂
I won’t go into the details because that’s part of the fun of watching it unfold. I will say that a couple of visual moments made me roll my eyes, and I wasn’t convinced every effect was necessary. But they didn’t spoil the overall experience for me.
Fi’s Verdict: Is Behind Her Eyes Worth Watching?
Yes, 100%! It’s full of drama, suspense, agony, hope and love. I really enjoyed the way the answers arrive gradually rather than being given away at the beginning. There’s nothing worse than a mystery that tells you everything before you’ve had a chance to work it out yourself!
It builds steadily, and the characters slowly reveal more of themselves as the story develops. Six episodes felt just right for this kind of psychological thriller — enough time to draw me in without dragging things out.
It’s based on a standalone novel and was released as a limited series, so I wouldn’t go into it expecting a second season. Even so, it certainly leaves you with plenty to think about.
Best for: Fans of psychological thrillers, twisty mysteries and supernatural drama. If you enjoy trying to piece a story together while questioning everybody’s motives, this is well worth adding to your watch list.
More from On the Sofa with Fi
If you enjoyed this review, try my spoiler-free review of The Invisible Man for another unsettling psychological thriller, or my Pembrokeshire Murders review for a true-crime series.
For more spooky viewing, including films and series to watch this Halloween, explore my Halloween Fright Night recommendations for 2026.
In the mood for something lighter next? Take a look at my Emily in Paris review, or explore all my On the Sofa with Fi recommendations, where you can also sign up for my free monthly newsletter.
Have you watched Behind Her Eyes? Did you enjoy it as much as I did, or did those strange moments put you off? Let me know in the comments — but please, no spoilers for anyone who hasn’t seen it yet! 💜

Leave a Reply